Crime Scene 0: The corpse of Ferdinand von Dougsoc
Ferdinand's body (a deflated inflatable flamingo)
A visible stab wound (a line of red paint with a nearby paper blood splatter)
Chalk outline (on some conveniently-placed chalkboards under the body)
Loose stuffing
Crime Scene 1: Eevil MacKill's location
"Other Hobbies" - miniature painting supplies
A list of suspect's dietary requirements
Ferdinand von Dougsoc: Deathly allergic to celery
Eevil MacKill: None
Turnip von Dougsoc: Allergic to Soy
Bear Daddy: Halal
Bitey O'Sharke: Pescetarian
Polly McGraw: Vegan (Not any more, January's over)
Detective Fiction (this is DougSoc, so we used Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency)
Crime Scene 2: Turnip von Dougsoc's location
Tickets to the World Solitaire Championships for himself and Ferdinand
Play-doh
Empty rucksack
Crime Scene 3: Bear Daddy's location
Love letters from Ferdinand
Letter opener
Travel Cluedo
Empty bottles of "Booze" and "Vodka"
UoY Graduation plush duck
Crime Scene 4: Bitey O'Sharke's location
2 packs of playing cards (the intial plan was to have one of these be clearly doctored)
Spear
Plush "Among Us" character
Crime Scene 5: Polly McGraw's location
Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream packet
Feast Ice cream packet (inside the B+J)
"Lethally sharp" heels
A key leading to a [Spoilers, highlight to see] stash of weapons with a flamingo on the keyring
Printout of a murder scene folded into a paper aeroplane
Various balls of scrunched-up paper
Plastic cups and glasses strewn around the floor, as if they've had a rowdy party